Back to blogs
Selling Strategy4 min read

An offer is more than its price: what sellers should compare before accepting

By Ben Price · Posted

A homeowner comparing two property offer documents alongside a calendar, calculator and house keys.

An offer arrives and your eyes go straight to the price. That is understandable. It is the number you have been waiting for.

Before deciding, ask your agent to put the whole proposal in front of you. A higher figure with several unresolved conditions asks you to weigh a different set of possibilities from another offer with different terms. Neither deserves an automatic yes or no.

The aim is to understand what you would be agreeing to, what still needs to happen and how the arrangement fits your next move.

Put the offers side by side

Ask for a written comparison using the same headings for each buyer:

  • Offered price and any requested inclusions or exclusions.
  • Deposit amount, payment timing and proposed arrangements.
  • Finance, building, pest or other conditions, with their deadlines.
  • Proposed settlement date and any possession or access requests.
  • Offer expiry and anything still awaiting clarification.

Keep unanswered questions visible. A blank beside “finance” should prompt a question, not an assumption that finance is settled. Ask your agent to distinguish what the buyer has confirmed from what the agent expects.

Read the conditions, not just their labels

In Victoria, Consumer Affairs Victoria explains that agreed private-sale conditions can include finance, the sale of another property and inspections. WA Consumer Protection also identifies finance, building or termite inspections and the sale of another property as possible special conditions. These are state-specific examples, not a national contract template.

Ask your solicitor or conveyancer to explain the actual wording: what must happen, by when, who must give notice and what happens if the requirement is not met. A heading such as “subject to inspection” does not answer those questions on its own.

For a finance condition, ask what information is available about the buyer’s progress and what remains outstanding. For an inspection condition, clarify the process and deadline. Avoid treating enthusiasm, a large deposit or a reassuring label as a guarantee of completion.

Work through the dates and practical costs

Choose a settlement date by looking at your own commitments, rather than assuming earlier is always better. Consider moving arrangements, another purchase, storage and accommodation. Ask the relevant advisers what a mismatch could mean for you.

Check requests involving furniture, appliances, repairs or early access too. A price comparison can be misleading if one proposal includes items or obligations that the other does not. Ask your legal adviser to check how any agreement would be recorded.

For illustration, imagine two offers with different prices and settlement dates. Instead of choosing from the figures alone, write down the extra costs and unresolved questions attached to each. This is a discussion aid, not a formula for predicting which sale will complete.

Get advice before you commit

The point at which a sale becomes binding and the buyer’s cooling-off rights depend on the jurisdiction and circumstances. NSW Government guidance describes exchange of contracts and cooling-off rules, while Consumer Affairs Victoria describes acceptance by signing and its own cooling-off framework. Do not carry assumptions from one state into another.

Before accepting, signing or agreeing to changed terms, have your solicitor or conveyancer review the proposal. Ask when you would be committed, what rights remain and which deadlines you need to track.

Your sales agent can negotiate with buyers and explain their recommendation. Your legal adviser should explain the contractual consequences. If the recommendation is simply “take the highest one”, ask for the reasoning across price, conditions and timing.

Support with your sale

BrokerMyAgent helps sellers across Australia find their best-fit agent. We research and compare suitable sales agents, review agents’ selling proposals, commission and marketing costs, challenge anything that doesn’t stack up, and support sellers through the process. You choose the sales agent who markets your property and negotiates with buyers. Our service is free to sellers. Agents pay us a standard introduction fee out of their own budget, never your pocket.

General information only, not legal or financial advice. Contract requirements and rights vary by state or territory and sale circumstances. Obtain advice for your property.

Talk it through first

No cost, no obligation.

Book a Free 15-Minute Call

Sources

Sources checked 10 November 2026. State-specific resources apply to that state only.

Get My Free Agent Shortlist